Avatar

[bloodyrosemccoy]

First off, I want to thank James Cameron for complicating my life, since I am also re-watching the entire series of Avatar: The Last Airbender, which is a mouthful to specify.

The movie was … well, for the Highest-Budget Highest-Grossing Movie Ever, with elements Relevant To My Interests,* there is no getting around that the story was basically a giant, special-effects-laden, two-hour-and-forty-two-minute rehash of FernGully: The Last Rainforest. You want race relations with aliens,** check out CJ Cherryh or Poul Anderson or someone of that ilk.

I’ll give it one thing, though—the worldbuilding was magnificent. I get as big a charge out of seeing a constructed world onscreen as I get out of hearing people converse in constructed languages. The worldbuilder in me who is satisfied with deliciously extrapolated ecosystems and what-ifs was all over this movie. Even the culture gets some bonus points—I have this image of James Cameron waving a stack of cash at a team of anthropologist consultants demanding “Make me a race of noble savage blue people!” and the consultants valiantly trying to give some verisimilitude to the Na’vi anyway.

Basically, if I had my way with the movie, it’d be a documentary. No plot except maybe Sigourney Weaver doing field anthropology or something.

I know, I know, it’s as much wishful thinking as wishing the Prime Directive were something that people would actually follow, but I can dream, can’t I?


*Special effects, worldbuilding, and blue people, for a start. Also my well-aged fancrush on Sigourney Weaver, and my burgeoning one on Zoë Saldaña. But “DOES IT HAVE ALIENS IN IT?” is the trump card.

**This actually really drives me nuts, that writers and readers of sci-fi so often equate race with species, to the point where they use the words interchangeably. There are indeed parallels, but there’s also, quite literally, a world of difference between humans and alien species. You don’t get a different evolutionary psychology (the real kind, not the pseudoscientific Stephen Jay Gould’s Strawman kind) or a different-shaped brain when you’re talking about two groups of humans. With aliens, well, we come back around to the GOOD sci-fi writers.

Comments

Re: Skipping the other issues...

[padparadscha.livejournal.com]

That bugged me, too--in fact, it kept throwing me off, because there's an old Poul Anderson story where the fact that the one-with-nature blue people who are getting encroached upon by humans are the only non-hexapods on their world is a PLOT POINT.

They have some explanation for it in a book I checked out--remember th lemur things with the fused upper arms? Apparently they're evolutionary precursors to the Na'vi, who have fused entirely. Which brings up SO MANY QUESTIONS.

I was okay with the use of reef life as the local flora and fauna, myself. At least it wasn't all just a bunch of mashup mammals.

Re: Skipping the other issues...

[biomekanic.livejournal.com]

I found the reef life to be sort of a cheat, "we're going all out with some things, but let's Cliff Notes this part, who'll be able to tell?"

I forgot about the lemurs till you mentioned it. Still, bugged me and continues to bug me.

I will say though, that the CGI was very impressive, the Na'vi didn't hit the uncanny valley like so many other CGI people have, at least for me. I found the kids in Polar Express kind of creepy.

With Cameron remaking Fern Gully/Dances with Wolves with the first movie in this trilogy, I wonder what's next? Seven Samurai?

Re: Skipping the other issues...

[redkite7.livejournal.com]

Hi! Here from metaquotes. The ikrans / banshees only had 4 limbs also, but toruk had 6, so...

that was weird to me too.